Half-term arrives and suddenly everybody wants data.
Attainment.
Progress.
Attendance.
Behaviour.
Intervention groups.
Disadvantaged pupils.
SEND.
Homework.
Reading ages.
Assessment scores.
By the time all of it has been entered, colour-coded and discussed, it is possible to produce a very impressive spreadsheet without changing anything for a single pupil.
That is the danger of half-term data checks.
The useful question is not:
“What data can we collect?”
It is:
“What do we need to know now that will change what we do next?”
That distinction matters for pupil learning and teacher workload.
Department for Education guidance continues to emphasise that assessment information should come primarily from normal teaching and that schools should avoid creating additional evidence purely to populate tracking systems. Current Key Stage 2 teacher-assessment guidance explicitly says schools should consider teacher workload when deciding what assessment data needs to be recorded.
So a useful half-term review should be selective.
It should identify pupils, groups and areas of learning that need attention.
Then it should stop collecting information and start making decisions.
This guide looks at the half-term data checks that are genuinely useful for teachers and school leaders—and the ones that can usually be simplified.
Start with the question the data is supposed to answer
Before asking staff to enter anything, decide why you need it.
Useful questions include
- Which pupils have not understood the key learning so far?
- Which pupils are beginning to fall behind?
- Are there groups whose experience is noticeably different?
- Which interventions appear to be helping?
- Where is attendance starting to affect learning?
- Which pupils need a conversation with home?
Less useful questions include
“Can we produce another column showing the same information differently?”
or:
“Would it be useful to colour-code every objective?”
Maybe.
But only if somebody will use the result.
Use the decision test
For every data point, ask:
What decision could this information change?
If nobody can answer, reconsider whether the data needs collecting.
This principle is consistent with DfE workload guidance, which says every data collection should have a clear purpose and should be carried out as efficiently as possible.
Check what pupils actually know, not just what percentage they scored
An assessment score is useful.
It is not the whole story.
Two pupils may both score 62% while having completely different learning needs.
Look behind the number
Ask:
- Which questions were commonly missed?
- Which concepts caused difficulty?
- Was the problem knowledge, vocabulary or application?
- Did pupils misunderstand the question?
- Was there a common misconception?
Use class-level patterns
Suppose:
- 26 pupils understand fractions;
- 22 can compare them;
- only 11 can explain why two fractions are equivalent.
That tells you something useful about teaching.
An average class score of 71% tells you much less.
Assessment should feed instruction
EEF guidance on feedback stresses that teachers need information about the gap between current and desired understanding so that teaching and feedback can respond appropriately.
That makes the most useful half-term assessment question:
“What should we teach differently next?”
not:
“What colour should this pupil be on the spreadsheet?”
Look for pupils drifting, not only pupils already far behind
Half-term is early enough to notice small changes.
That is one of its biggest advantages.
Do not only look at the bottom group
A pupil who started strongly but has recently:
- stopped completing work;
- missed several lessons;
- begun handing in weaker homework;
- become much quieter;
may deserve more attention than a pupil who is consistently working below age-related expectations but already has appropriate support in place.
Look for movement
Ask:
- Who is improving?
- Who is static?
- Who is beginning to slip?
Use teacher knowledge alongside the data
Half-term checks should not override what teachers are seeing.
If a pupil's score appears secure but their classroom independence has deteriorated, that matters.
If another pupil's formal assessment is weak but daily work shows clear improvement, that matters too.
The AllSchools guide A Six-Week Review Checklist for a New Class is useful for bringing learning, behaviour, SEND, friendships and attendance together rather than reviewing attainment in isolation.
Check attendance alongside attainment
Attainment data without attendance context can be misleading.
Ask whether lost learning explains part of the picture
A pupil who has missed:
- one isolated day;
is different from a pupil who has:
- missed every Monday;
- had repeated short illnesses;
- arrived late several times each week.
Look at the trajectory
A pupil does not need to have reached persistent absence before attendance deserves attention.
Check pupils whose attendance is:
- declining;
- showing repeated patterns;
- beginning to affect curriculum access.
Do not automatically assume attendance caused low attainment
Sometimes the direction works the other way.
A child struggling academically may begin avoiding school.
Another pupil may be experiencing anxiety, bullying or SEND-related difficulty.
Attendance data should start a question.
It should not automatically provide the answer.
For a wider leadership review, see A Practical Autumn Attendance Review for School Leaders.
Review pupil groups carefully, but avoid meaningless averages
Schools rightly look at groups.
For example:
- disadvantaged pupils;
- SEND pupils;
- boys and girls;
- pupils with English as an additional language;
- different prior-attainment groups.
The problem is small numbers
Imagine a year group has five pupils in one category.
One pupil having a difficult assessment can shift the percentage dramatically.
Do not confuse a percentage with a pattern
If 60% of a group met an expectation, ask:
- How many pupils is that?
- Which pupils?
- What is actually different about their learning?
Move from group data to pupil names
“SEND pupils are underperforming” is not an intervention.
Instead:
“Four pupils with SEND are struggling with extended written responses despite strong verbal understanding.”
Now you have something teachers can respond to.
Check whether interventions are changing anything
Schools can accumulate interventions.
Reading groups.
Maths tutoring.
Mentoring.
Homework clubs.
Phonics catch-up.
Pastoral programmes.
The half-term review is a good time to ask whether they are actually helping.
For each intervention, ask
- Why was the pupil placed in it?
- What was supposed to improve?
- What evidence would show improvement?
- Has that happened?
Do not measure everything
If the intervention is intended to improve reading fluency, you may need:
- a relevant reading measure;
- teacher observation;
- perhaps classroom transfer.
You probably do not need twelve new indicators.
Know when to stop
An intervention should not continue indefinitely simply because it has always happened on Tuesday mornings.
If pupils no longer need it, stop.
If it is not working, change it.
If it is working, understand why and decide what happens next.
Look at behaviour data for patterns, not totals
A headline such as:
“Year 8 has 147 behaviour incidents.”
may sound concerning.
It may also tell you very little.
Ask where the incidents occur
Look at:
- times of day;
- subjects;
- locations;
- pupil groups;
- types of incident;
- repeat pupils.
One small group may drive a large percentage
If six pupils account for most incidents, the response is different from a widespread deterioration across a year group.
Look for classroom patterns too
You may find that incidents spike:
- during transitions;
- after lunch;
- during cover lessons;
- during extended independent work.
That suggests a routine or curriculum-design question as well as a behaviour question.
If classroom expectations need revisiting, see How to Reset Expectations After a Difficult First Month.
Prepare useful information for parents’ evening
Half-term data collection often sits close to the first formal parent meetings.
That makes this a good test of whether the information you have collected is actually useful.
Parents rarely need a spreadsheet
They want to know:
- Is my child doing well?
- What are their strengths?
- What are they finding difficult?
- What should improve next?
Translate scores into learning
Instead of:
“She is currently at 68% and working towards.”
say:
“She understands the main maths methods but still finds multi-step problems difficult when she has to decide independently which method to use.”
If teachers cannot explain the data simply, reconsider the measure
Useful tracking should help teachers explain learning more clearly.
It should not create a second language that only the tracking system understands.
The AllSchools guide How to Plan the First Parents’ Evening From Your Notes shows how to turn classroom information into concise parent conversations.
Keep pupil progress meetings focused on decisions
A pupil progress meeting can become a slow reading of the spreadsheet.
Teacher:
“This pupil is working towards.”
Leader:
“Okay.”
Teacher:
“This one is expected.”
That is not a useful use of professional time.
Start with exceptions
Discuss pupils who:
- are falling behind;
- have made unexpected progress;
- are not responding to support;
- have new attendance or behaviour patterns;
- need a specific decision.
Ask action questions
For example:
- What is the main barrier?
- What have we already tried?
- What will change?
- Who will do it?
- When will we review it?
End with fewer, clearer actions
A good meeting might create:
- five meaningful actions;
rather than:
- thirty vague targets.
See How to Run a Pupil Progress Meeting Efficiently.
Stop collecting data that does not change anything
Half-term is also a good time to review the data system itself.
Ask staff
“What are you entering that nobody seems to use?”
The answers may be uncomfortable.
Common examples include
- duplicating assessment information in two systems;
- recording every tiny curriculum statement;
- creating artificial progress points between short assessment windows;
- producing reports that are never discussed.
Technology can make unnecessary collection easier
That does not make it necessary.
DfE workload groups have repeatedly warned that digital systems can either reduce workload or make excessive data collection easier to expand.
Use the removal test
Ask:
“If we stopped collecting this tomorrow, what useful decision would we no longer be able to make?”
If the answer is:
“None that we can think of,”
you may have found something to remove.
A useful half-term data checklist
Attainment and learning
- Which concepts are secure?
- Which misconceptions are common?
- Which pupils are beginning to drift?
- What needs reteaching?
Attendance
- Which pupils are deteriorating?
- Are there repeated day-of-week patterns?
- Is absence affecting curriculum access?
Behaviour
- Where are incidents concentrated?
- Are a small number of pupils driving the data?
- Are particular routines or lessons involved?
Groups
- Are any meaningful gaps emerging?
- Which actual pupils sit behind those averages?
- Is the group large enough for the percentage to mean anything?
Interventions
- What is each intervention supposed to improve?
- Is there evidence that it is doing so?
- Should it continue, change or stop?
Next steps
- Which pupils require action?
- What will change in teaching or support?
- Who owns the action?
- When will it be reviewed?
If a data check cannot produce answers to those final questions, it may not yet be useful enough.
Frequently asked questions
Do schools need to collect assessment data every half-term?
There is no general requirement that every school must run a particular half-termly tracking cycle. Schools should collect information that supports teaching, statutory requirements and leadership decisions while considering teacher workload. Current DfE teacher-assessment guidance explicitly advises schools to minimise unnecessary recording.
Should every subject produce a numerical grade at half-term?
Not necessarily. The most useful assessment format depends on the subject, age and purpose. In some cases, identifying secure knowledge and misconceptions may be more useful than forcing performance into a number.
How much data should be discussed in a pupil progress meeting?
Only enough to identify priorities and agree action. Teachers and leaders do not need to verbally review every pupil where there is no concern or decision to make.
Should leaders compare different classes?
They can, but comparisons need context. Different cohorts, assessment design, SEND profiles and curriculum sequencing can make apparently simple comparisons misleading.
Are percentages useful for small pupil groups?
They can be misleading. Always look at the actual number of pupils and their individual circumstances before drawing conclusions from a percentage.
Should behaviour and attendance be reviewed alongside attainment?
Yes. They can help explain changes in learning and reveal barriers that an assessment score alone cannot show.
Should teachers create new assessments just for the data drop?
Usually the starting point should be evidence already generated through normal teaching and appropriate assessment. DfE guidance warns against creating additional evidence simply to demonstrate assessment statements.
How do we know whether an intervention is working?
Define the intended outcome before or at the start of the intervention, then use a small number of relevant measures to see whether that outcome is improving.
What if teacher judgement disagrees with the test result?
Investigate why. One assessment may have captured a bad day, while teacher judgement may also be over-optimistic or based on supported work. Use multiple relevant pieces of evidence rather than automatically privileging one source.
Should we track every curriculum objective?
Only where doing so serves a clear teaching or leadership purpose. Tracking every tiny statement can create large amounts of work without necessarily producing better instructional decisions.
What should governors see?
Governors generally need strategic patterns, trends and the school's response rather than raw classroom-level spreadsheets. Leaders should provide information that allows governance to understand priorities and challenge appropriately.
What is the most useful half-term data question?
Probably:
“What will we do differently because we now know this?”
If there is a clear answer, the data is doing useful work.
If there is not, it may simply be adding workload.
Half-term data checks should help schools notice what is changing while there is still plenty of time to respond.
They should reveal pupils beginning to drift.
They should identify misconceptions worth reteaching.
They should show where attendance or behaviour is interfering with learning.
They should tell leaders whether interventions are worth continuing.
And they should help teachers enter the next half-term with clearer priorities.
They should not require staff to manufacture a mountain of evidence simply because the calendar says “data drop”.
Collect less.
Look at it more carefully.
Connect numbers with teacher knowledge.
Then turn the important findings into action.
A useful half-term review does not end with a completed spreadsheet.
It ends with somebody knowing exactly what needs to happen next.